I just picked up my skates!
They are the Riedell 121's in a Mens' D width (which seems to be a really new thing--it wasn't mentioned in the 2012 catalog I had). My skate fitter seemed happy with the way they fit me and I like how they don't hurt like the too narrow rentals I've been wearing.
(Although I'm grateful that the rentals were included in the price when I was just beginning...I'm so happy to have my own!)