Jim at Hackensack needs an appointment and maybe a wait time so if you want to see him e-mail ahead. Their shop has all the basics, some non-basics, a lot of Zuca bags and accessories and some training clothes and dresses but more in kid sizes.
If you're just looking for stuff, Westside Skate in Chelsea has most of the basics and clothes. SkyRink at Chelsea Piers has some stuff too, more for kids also and more hockey than figure skating. Really depends on what you are looking for.